Book: Dissolving Illusions - Disease, Vaccines, and The Forgotten History

Purchase: amazon

"Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and The Forgotten History," authored by Dr. Suzanne Humphries and Roman Bystrianyk, provides a critical examination of the history and efficacy of vaccines. The book challenges the conventional narrative that vaccines are the primary reason for the decline of infectious diseases in the modern world. Through extensive historical research and analysis, the authors aim to provide a different perspective on the role of vaccines and the factors that contributed to improved public health outcomes.

Premise and Overview ​

"Dissolving Illusions" explores the decline of infectious diseases from the 19th to the 20th century, arguing that the reduction in disease prevalence and mortality rates was largely due to improvements in sanitation, nutrition, and living conditions, rather than solely the introduction of vaccines. The book meticulously details historical records, data, and personal accounts to support its thesis that social and environmental advancements played a more significant role in combating diseases.

Historical Context and Evidence 

The authors delve into the history of various infectious diseases, such as smallpox, polio, and measles, examining the conditions under which these diseases flourished and eventually waned. They provide evidence showing that mortality rates for many infectious diseases had already been declining before the widespread use of vaccines. For instance, improvements in water quality, sewage systems, and food safety are highlighted as key factors that contributed to the reduction in disease incidence.

England and Wales mortality rates from various infectious diseases from 1838 to 1978. (Record of mortality in England and Wales for 95 years as provided by the Office of National Statistics, published 1997; Report to The Honourable Sir George Cornewall Lewis, Bart, MP, Her Majesty’s Principal Secretary of State for the Home Department, June 30, 1860, pp. a4, 205; Essay on Vaccination by Charles T. Pearce, MD, Member of the Royal College of Surgeons of England; Parliamentary Papers, the 62nd Annual Return of the Registrar General 1899 (1891–1898))

Smallpox and Vaccination 

One of the central topics in the book is smallpox, a disease often cited as a major success story for vaccination. "Dissolving Illusions" questions the effectiveness of the smallpox vaccine and presents historical data suggesting that smallpox outbreaks were often controlled through quarantine measures and improvements in living conditions rather than vaccination alone. The authors argue that compulsory vaccination policies sometimes led to severe adverse effects and public resistance.

Polio and Public Health

Forgotten History and Public Perception 

The book also critically examines the history of polio, another disease frequently associated with the triumph of vaccines. Humphries and Bystrianyk argue that the dramatic drop in polio cases was influenced by better hygiene practices, changes in diagnostic criteria, and the natural evolution of the disease. They present a nuanced view of the introduction of the polio vaccine, highlighting controversies and challenges that accompanied its rollout.

"Dissolving Illusions" emphasizes that much of the historical context surrounding disease and public health has been forgotten or overshadowed by the dominant vaccine narrative. The authors aim to restore this history by bringing to light lesser-known facts and perspectives. They argue that a more comprehensive understanding of the past can inform current public health policies and practices.

Conclusion and Implications 

The book concludes with a call for a balanced and critical approach to understanding the role of vaccines in public health. The authors advocate for informed consent, transparency, and respect for individual autonomy in medical decisions. They urge readers to consider the broader context of disease prevention, including the importance of nutrition, sanitation, and overall health improvement.
​
"Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and The Forgotten History" offers a thought-provoking perspective on the history of disease and vaccination. By revisiting historical evidence and challenging established narratives, the book invites readers to reconsider the complex factors that have shaped public health outcomes over the past two centuries.